Coconut Berry Sundae with Homemade Peanut Butter Chocolate Drizzle

If there’s anything that the 4th of July week can remind us of, it’s that you can’t let the classics fade away. Per usual, I spent my holiday finding ways to “healthify” a classic: the ice cream sundae. Instead of jarred fudge, maraschino cherries and brownies, this coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle has fresh cut fruit and nut butters for protein.

Most of the time I prefer to make my own “nice cream” out of bananas and coconut cream, but sometimes I indulge and get the real thing. SO Delicious is a quick option and my go-to splurge when I buy premade ice cream. They have coconut and cashew flavors and do a good job of making creamy dairy free ice creams. I used their coconut milk ice cream for this coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle recipe.

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzleFresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzleFresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle

Homemade Peanut Butter Chocolate Drizzle

Do you remember Magic Shell topping from back in the day? It used to be my favorite thing. My childhood had a lot of ice cream sundaes, and the magic shell was always an added joy because it was like bringing the Dairy Queen dips home into your kitchen. Fancy stuff.

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle

I wouldn’t buy the pre-made toppings now, but the concept of a delicious, hardened topping for my sundae didn’t necessarily disappear from my kitchen. It turns out nut butter works in the same way as magic shell, but is completely natural. That is why I melted chocolate and peanut butter together for a magic shell reminiscent, yet healthy and natural, topping for this coconut berry sundae.

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle

Dairy Free Ice Cream

For me growing up, summer time included lots of ice cream sundaes after long days playing outdoors. It was a special experience when my family would sit out on the back patio and churn homemade ice cream together. Nothing beats homemade, but that’s not really realistic all the time, at least for me! When I switched to being dairy free I cut out all ice cream, mostly because there weren’t many options. I learned to make my own dairy free alternatives like this banana PB chocolate chip “milkshake.” But it is nice to have a go-to, ready-made ice cream that’s dairy free for times when you want to splurge.

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle

Coconut Berry Sundae with Vanilla Coconut Milk Ice Cream

I used So Delicous Coconut Milk Ice Cream for this coconut berry sundae. The vanilla coconut milk ice cream pairs nicely with the fruit flavors and makes you feel transported to a tropical vacation. (Maybe that’s just me missing Belize! why does vacation always have to end so quickly!) The other great thing about this sundae is that it highlights some of my favorite summer fruits: blueberries and nectarines. Naturally accented and fruit flavored sundaes for the win!

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzleFresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle

Disclaimer:  So delicious provided product for this recipe. All opinions are my own and I only write about products I use. 

These didn’t last long in our house. I couldn’t even snap a few pictures without a few bites going missing. 🙂 I guess that’s compliments to the chef. Hopefully, they are a hit in your household, too!

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle

 

Looking for other healthy frozen treats this summer? Try the Dairy free, gluten free, sugar free and absolutely delicious Peanut Butter Banana Chocolate Chip Smoothie. 

Healthy Peanut Butter Cup Shake that's deliciously dairy free, grain free, and refined sugar free

Or go for a fruitier option with this Cantaloupe Lassi

Cantaloupe Lassi - Paleo, Dairy Free and Gluten Free

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle
Print

Coconut Berry Sundae with Homemade Peanut Butter Chocolate Drizzle

Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, and a healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle recipe

Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Prep Time 15 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes
Servings 4 people
Author Alicia

Ingredients

Ingredients

  • 1 pint vanilla coconut milk ice cream by So Delicious
  • 1 nectarine
  • 1/2 cup blueberries
  • 3 tbsp chocolate chips dairy free and soy free
  • 2 tbsp natural chunky peanut butter

Instructions

Directions:

  1. Thinly dice the nectarine to pieces just longer than a blueberry. This is best done by first cutting the nectarine into thin slices and then dicing the nectarine slices.

    Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle
  2. In a small bowl, melt the chocolate chips and peanut butter together. If using the microwave, heat for 22 seconds, then stir before heating for another 11 seconds.  If using the double broiler, stir every 15 seconds until fully melted, about 1-2 minutes. After either method, remove the mixture from heat, stir to evenly combine the peanut butter and chocolate, and set aside. 

  3. Scoop the coconut ice cream evenly across 4 bowls using an ice cream scoop or large spoon

  4. Spread the diced nectarines and blueberries on top of the ice cream, distributing them evenly across each bowl

    Fresh berries, creamy coconut ice cream, healthy magic shell make this great dairy free coconut berry sundae with homemade peanut butter chocolate drizzle
  5. Using a spoon, drizzle the chocolate peanut butter mixture across the tops of the bowls, spreading evenly among the bowls

  6. serve and enjoy!

Recipe Notes

Notes: use a natural peanut butter for a better effect. If you are allergic to peanuts or prefer other nut butters, you can substitute at equal quantities for another nut butter, such as almond butter. 

9 Comments Add yours

  1. Amanda says:

    That looks ridiculously amazing and I can never say no to chocolate and peanut butter!

    1. Alicia says:

      I’m a sucker for the chocolate peanut butter combo too!

  2. That homemade drizzle would get eaten up quickly around here (although we’d have to use SunButter).

    1. Alicia says:

      It would work just as well with sun butter. I haven’t tried tahini yet but I bet that would be good too!!

  3. I love the way you’ve paired fresh fruit with my favorite ice cream toppings – chocolate AND peanut butter together. Yum!! Making this soon.

    1. Alicia says:

      I can’t say no to fruit, chocolate and peanut butter. It’s borderline a problem 😉

  4. This magic shell sounds great! I love this idea. Fresh fruit is always a plus too

    1. Alicia says:

      Thanks Lindsey! I love how the nut butter naturally hardens into that classic childhood topping 🙂 and I agree, fruit makes everything tastier

Ask a question and leave a comment!